Impostor 1893 "O" Morgan Silver Dollar

Sometimes you see something and it's just too good to be true. That was the case with the most recent batch of Sterling scrap I got. It looked decent enough at first glance, but then I noticed something interesting.

When I looked in the bag, it had what looked like a Morgan dollar in it.

The 1893 year piqued my interest, so I opened it.


Holy cow! An 1893 "O" Morgan! For those who don't know, this coin in far worse condition than this go for $200 easily. There are so few left, these are hard to come by. No way someone accidentally included a $200 coin in a lot of scrap.

So, I grabbed my Sigma to test it.

It failed the pre-1900 test.

It wasn't even close on the pre-1945 test. I was 99.99% sure by now that it's a fake.

I grabbed my 1921 Morgan dollar and weighed it.

Then I weighed the suspect "Morgan dollar."

Not even close!

A real Morgan dollar is 38mm in diamater.

The fake, not so much.

Some of the fakes were still made of 90% silver, so I'm going to take it in to the pawn shop near me. There are a couple of other pieces that are also suspect, so I'm going to ask them to test them with their XRF gun in order to identify the composition. If it's still 90% silver then I'll still come out ahead on the lot. If it's not, you can bet I'm getting a refund.

1000017156.gif

1000033547.jpg
Buy DUO and stake to receive Hive dividends, tip others, have your posts curated, and grow Hive!
https://tribaldex.com/trade/DUO
https://hive-engine.com/trade/DUO




Do you like stacking gold and silver?

Are you new to Hive, or know someone new to Hive, and want help and support?

Have you been on Hive for a while and want to help new Hive members? Join HOC and help us grow Hive and encourage new members!

Posted Using INLEO

Sort:  

You received an upvote of 100% from Precious the Silver Mermaid!

Thank you for contributing more great content to the #SilverGoldStackers tag.
You have created a Precious Gem!

Congratulations @bulliontools! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain And have been rewarded with New badge(s)

You got more than 11000 replies.
Your next target is to reach 11500 replies.

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Check out our last posts:

Hive Power Up Day - May 1st 2026

Did you do the 'PING' test? Just for good measure.
I used to check out another Coin and jewelry shop in Vancouver when I had patents to check on in the area a few years back. That coin and jewelry shop would charge me $10 CAD to do a XRF reading on a suspect coin.

!PIMP

I did the ping test and it sounded slightly off, but not so off that I wouldn't rule out silver. If it was just the coin I wouldn't bother, but there are two other pieces that are suspect. If any one of the three are truly silver then I've made money on the deal. The last time I was in they didn't charge me, but if they do I'm not too worried.

!BBH
!PIZZA
!ALIVE

Ugh, people are just horrible!

In this case I honestly think it was ignorance rather than a deliberate attempt to scam. The rest of the pieces are Sterling or at least 80-90% silver.

!BBH
!PIZZA
!ALIVE

Okay, I take it back then! :)

I hope it is still 90% silver, you still win that way! However, that thing is technically counterfeit and illegal to own so you may want to get it melted quickly if it's silver!

You can tell it's a fake pretty much at first glance though, it may look worn but it's not. It wasn't struck right and their are no bag marks like a real Morgan would have. Your instincts were right to check it out. I hate scammers...

!PIMP
!BBH
!PIZZA

I'm hoping it's still 90% silver as well. I don't think they were trying to scam me. I'm guessing they thought it was real and threw it in or they knew it was fake but real silver, so weight is still weight. I'll find out soon enough. 🙂

!BBH
!PIZZA
!ALIVE

PIZZA!

$PIZZA slices delivered:
silversaver888 tipped bulliontools
bulliontools tipped bozz
bulliontools tipped kerrislravenhill
bulliontools tipped thebighigg
thebighigg tipped bulliontools
@bulliontools(9/20) tipped @silversaver888

Please vote for pizza.witness!

I cannot understand faking a coin... especially if the fake is made of silver!
!BBH
!LADY
!PIZZA


View or trade LOH tokens.


@silversaver888, you successfully shared 0.1000 LOH with @bulliontools and you earned 0.1000 LOH as tips. (1/50 calls)

Use !LADY command to share LOH! More details available in this post.

Well, authentic ones are worth $200+, so to some it could be worth the effort at least when silver was cheaper.

!BBH
!PIZZA
!ALIVE