Dead Soldiers (S03E03)
Airdate: October 3rd 2004
Written by: Dennis Lehane
Directed by: Rob Bailey
Running Time: 58 minutes
David Simon’s masterstroke in The Wire lay not only in his own incisive vision but in his deliberate curation of literary talent to dissect Baltimore’s rot. Barely a week after showcasing Richard Price’s formidable skills in Season 3’s All Due Respect, Simon handed the reins to Dennis Lehane, the Boston-bred novelist whose gritty narratives – Mystic River, Gone, Baby, Gone – had already cemented his reputation and would soon fuel major cinematic adaptations throughout the early 2000s. Lehane’s debut, Dead Soldiers, proved an immediate and potent addition to the series’ tapestry. Far from a tentative step, it demonstrated a profound understanding of Simon’s core thesis: the systemic decay of institutions and the human cost of dealing with them. Lehane embedded himself within the show’s DNA, establishing him as a vital voice in The Wire’s unparalleled exploration of urban America.
The episode’s title, "Dead Soldiers," operates with chilling duality, embodying the show’s signature linguistic precision. Literally, it’s street slang for an empty liquor bottle – a discarded vessel, a spent resource. Yet, metaphorically, it pierces the heart of the narrative, referring to two pivotal deaths: one within the criminal underworld, the other within the police department. These aren’t grand, heroic falls, but sudden, ignominious extinguishments that ripple through the fragile ecosystems of both sides of the law, exposing the brutal randomness and profound consequences of lives lived on the edge. The first death erupts from Omar Little’s fatal miscalculation. Disregarding Kimmy’s pragmatic counsel – that Baltimore teems with easier targets than the recently torched and hyper-vigilant Barksdale organisation – Omar insists on another stash house raid. Kimmy’s scepticism is catastrophically vindicated. The Barksdales, paranoid and heavily armed after their previous losses, have transformed the location into a death trap. What should have been Omar’s trademark surgical strike descends into a chaotic, close-quarters street battle. In the smoke and confusion, Dante’s stray bullet claims Tosha, Kimmy’s old partner. Kimmy’s immediate, visceral retaliation – gunning down Barksdale soldier Tank (Jonathan B. Wray) – is pure, unvarnished street justice. Omar, however, is shattered. He doesn’t revel in the violence; he internalises Tosha’s death as a personal failure, a devastating consequence of dragging others into his solitary, vendetta-driven war. The "dead soldier" here is Tosha – a casualty of Omar’s hubris, his misplaced loyalty to a personal code that bleeds innocents.
The second death arrives off-screen: Ray Cole, McNulty’s former Homicide colleague, has collapsed and died in the police gym. What follows isn’t a formal funeral, but the raw, extended ritual of the bar wake – a space where police grief, cynicism, and dark humour collide. Jay Landsman’s drunken, emotional eulogy is the episode’s soul. He doesn’t mythologise Cole as a flawless detective; instead, he mourns the humanity beneath the flawed cop – the man who wasn’t the best, yet got it right sometimes. This scene transcends mere plot; it’s a deeply meta-textual homage. Roland F. Collesbery, the actor who played Cole and a crucial executive producer instrumental in The Wire’s authenticity (having worked on Mississippi Burning and After Hours), suffered an identical sudden death months after Season 2 wrapped. Landsman’s specific, seemingly throwaway references to those very projects are not coincidental. They are Simon and Lehane’s direct, poignant tribute to their fallen colleague, embedding real-world loss into the fictional narrative. Cole’s death, and the wake, become a vessel for the show’s own grief, blurring the lines between art and life in a manner few series dare attempt.
While the streets and bars process death, the corridors of power within the Baltimore Police Department churn with the living death of careers. Major Marvin Taylor (Barnett Lloyd), commander of the Eastern District, faces the brutal consequences of reaching desired crime statistics. Chastised by the ruthlessly pragmatic Deputy Commissioner Rawls for poor numbers – a metric prioritised over actual public safety – Taylor is summarily demoted and relieved of duty. His fate hangs like a spectre over Howard "Bunny" Colvin. Unlike Taylor and his peers, who readily falsify statistics to appease superiors, Colvin refuses. His defiance, however, manifests not in passive resistance but in the audacious, morally fraught experiment: forcibly relocating Western District drug trade to three isolated zones, allowing open-air markets in exchange for reduced violence elsewhere. To sell this radical, potentially career-ending scheme to his bewildered troops, Colvin resorts to the institutional lingua franca – lies. He frames it as a complex, long-term "sting operation," manipulating his men just as the system manipulates the statistics. This juxtaposition – Taylor destroyed for not lying, Colvin potentially saved by telling a massive lie – lays bare the perverse incentives poisoning the entire institution.
Lying, of course, is the lifeblood of politics, embodied perfectly by Councilman Tommy Carcetti. He publicly shifts blame for police funding shortfalls onto Mayor Royce, positioning himself as the reformer while ensuring Acting Commissioner Burrell takes the political bullet to protect the Mayor’s interests. Carcetti’s hypocrisy reaches its zenith at a fundraiser. He presents the flawless image: the devoted family man with his picture-perfect wife Jen (Megan Anderson) and children. The moment the family departs, the mask slips. Carcetti seizes the opportunity to engage in a crudesexual encounter with a woman met at the event. The jarring shift from calculated domesticity to base opportunism reveals the hollow core of his ambition – a microcosm of the systemic corruption Simon relentlessly exposes.
Lehane’s script is a masterclass in narrative economy and thematic resonance, seamlessly weaving these major arcs with quieter, equally potent subplots. McNulty’s dawning realisation that D’Angelo Barksdale was murdered, not a suicide, adds another layer to the unsolvable puzzle of institutional indifference, though his pursuit seems destined for oblivion. Kima Greggs confronts the personal cost of her dedication, recognising how her job has alienated her from Cheryl and her child, paradoxically drawing her closer to the similarly damaged McNulty. Cutty Wise experiences a glimpse of a redeemed life through Grace Sampson (Dravon James), an old flame who escaped the projects to become a schoolteacher. Her palpable discomfort around the former gangbanger and ex-convict is honest, yet her promise to leverage connections for legitimate work offers a fragile, hard-won hope – a stark contrast to the surrounding despair.
The episode’s most significant plot development, however, is the coldly efficient escalation of the Barksdale-Stanfield war. Observing Fruit’s dwindling profits, blamed on Barksdale encroachment, Marlo Stanfield doesn’t hesitate. He orders a pre-emptive strike, dispatching Barksdale soldiers with brutal, silent efficiency using baseball bats. This isn’t chaotic street violence; it’s corporate warfare, chilling in its precision and lack of emotion, signalling Marlo’s ruthless ascent and the inexorable hardening of the drug trade.
Dead Soldiers stands as one of The Wire’s most potent episodes, largely due to Lehane’s exceptional script. Rob Bailey’s direction is largely superb, capturing the show’s signature naturalism and emotional weight. However, a rare stumble mars the pivotal shootout sequence. Simon’s insistence on hyper-realism – avoiding clear choreography to mimic the confusion of actual gunfights – backfired. The circumstances of Tosha’s death became frustratingly ambiguous on screen, requiring Simon to later explain the sequence in interviews. It’s a minor, almost pedantic flaw in an otherwise flawless hour, a testament to how high the show’s storytelling bar was set. Yet, this single stumble cannot diminish the episode’s power. Lehane didn’t just write for The Wire; he wrote as The Wire. He understood that the true "dead soldiers" are not just Tosha or Ray Cole, but the ideals, the loyalties, and the very souls slowly extinguished within the crushing machinery of the Game – whether played on street corners, in police stations, or in the polished halls of City Hall. It’s a brutal, necessary elegy, and a near-perfect debut from a writer who belonged in Baltimore all along.
RATING: 7/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Leodex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9
