Hamsterdam (S03E04)
Airdate: October 10th 2004
Written by: George Pelecanos
Directed by: Ernest Dickerson
Running Time: 58 minutes
For decades, Western Europe, or at least the comfortable Anglophone and Nordic fantasy of it, was peddled to American audiences as a kinder, gentler reflection of their own society: possessing all the technological prowess and economic stability, yet miraculously devoid of the festering American sores – the intractable racial tensions, the pervasive street crime, the stifling censorship, the ultra-violent militarism of foreign policy, and, crucially, the troglodytic puritanism surrounding recreational drugs. Nowhere was this latter delusion more potent, nor more heavily mythologised by Hollywood screenwriters and devoured by impressionable teenagers and young adults, than in the perceived libertine paradise of the Netherlands, specifically Amsterdam. Countless films and television shows conjured the Dutch capital as a hedonistic heaven on earth, a place where sensible drug regulation coexisted with civilised living, a stark rebuke to American prohibitionist folly. It is this pervasive, romanticised European mirage that The Wire, in its unflinching dissection of the catastrophic US War on Drugs, deliberately invokes and then systematically demolishes in its audacious Season 3 episode, Hamsterdam. The very title, a deliberate mispronunciation of "Amsterdam" spat out by Baltimore’s street dwellers, signals the episode’s core thesis: the American attempt to replicate this European fantasy is not only doomed but inherently grotesque within the specific, brutal context of the American urban landscape.
"Hamsterdam" refers to the radical, clandestine policy enacted by Major Howard "Bunny" Colvin in Baltimore’s beleaguered Western District. Faced with an intolerable murder rate and the sheer futility of conventional policing against the drug trade, Colvin designates specific, derelict zones – vacant lots, condemned buildings – as de facto free-fire areas where the open sale and use of narcotics will be tacitly permitted, or at least ignored by his command. His immediate, pragmatic goal is simple: contain the violence, reduce the murders bleeding into residential streets, and restore a semblance of order for the beleaguered citizens. Colvin’s resolve is hardened during a raw, emotionally charged community meeting where residents, exhausted and terrified, voice their despair. Significantly, this meeting is attended by City Councilman Tommy Carcetti, whose district lies far from the Western precinct. Carcetti’s presence is not altruism; it is the opening gambit in his audacious, seemingly quixotic plan to run for Mayor of Baltimore. His ambition is met with immediate, blunt scepticism – how can a white man possibly win in a majority-Black city? This cynicism is initially shared by Theresa d’Agostino (Brandy Burre), the sharp, DC-based political consultant Carcetti hopes to recruit, who views his mayoral bid as politically naive bordering on foolish. Colvin’s experiment, therefore, unfolds against the backdrop of nascent political ambition, where solutions are sought not just for moral or practical reasons, but as potential stepping stones to higher office.
Colvin’s implementation of "Hamsterdam," however, swiftly reveals the chasm between theoretical policy and street reality. The corner boys, immersed in their immediate, hyper-local turf wars and survival instincts, possess little awareness of, or capacity to comprehend, abstract concepts like "Hamsterdam" or Swiss drug policy. When Colvin’s officers attempt to persuade dealers to relocate to the designated zones – using intimidation as the primary tool – the effort is met with confusion, disbelief, and outright refusal. The dealers simply cannot process the notion of state-sanctioned drug markets; the very idea contradicts their lived experience of relentless police pressure. Driven to desperation, Colvin resorts to a more direct, almost authoritarian approach: rounding up the young dealers en masse and assembling them in a local school gymnasium to explain his vision. This gathering, however, descends into predictable chaos, a microcosm of the breakdown in authority. Order is only momentarily restored not by the police, but by the elderly school principal – a figure representing genuine, earned community respect that the police utterly lack. The scene is devastating: the dealers, many barely past school age, exhibit more deference to the principal than to the armed representatives of the state, highlighting the profound alienation of the police from the community they ostensibly serve.
Meanwhile, the Major Case Unit, ostensibly the city’s elite investigative force, flounders in irrelevance. Officially tasked with targeting low-level, independent dealers (a directive McNulty scorns as trivial compared to his obsession with Stringer Bell), the unit is further crippled by the fallout from the disastrous Cheese wiretap operation. McNulty’s relentless, near-solipsistic pursuit of Bell, conducted with scant regard for the unit’s cohesion or his colleagues’ efforts, brings him perilously close to open conflict with the normally unflappable Lester Freamon. Yet, McNulty’s doggedness yields a critical breakthrough: he discovers that Stringer Bell, unlike his street-level lieutenants who use disposable burners, operates on a genuine, traceable phone line. This single piece of detective work allows McNulty to physically tail Bell, peeling back the layers of his ambition. He uncovers Bell’s legitimate business partnerships – with wealthy land developer Andy Krawczyk and the corrupt state senator Clay Davis – revealing that Bell’s real estate ventures are not merely money laundering but a calculated, sophisticated bid to transcend the drug trade entirely and establish himself as a legitimate power broker within Baltimore’s establishment. Simultaneously, McNulty’s investigation into the rising Marlo Stanfield begins; a chilling conversation with Homicide’s Detective Holley (Brian Anthony Wilson) introduces Marlo as pure, calculated "evil," a 22-year-old already capable of cold-blooded witness elimination, marking him as a terrifying new force.
McNulty’s professional triumphs are starkly counterpointed by profound personal collapse. His desperate hope for reconciliation with his estranged wife evaporates as he realises her sole interest is maximising alimony. Seeking solace in Rhonda Pearlman, he instead descends into drunken despair, culminating in a humiliating, late-night confrontation at her door. There, he discovers the ultimate betrayal: Pearlman is having an affair with his direct superior, Lieutenant Cedric Daniels. This revelation forces an excruciatingly awkward encounter between McNulty and Daniels in a bar, a scene thick with unspoken tension and shattered trust, underscoring how the corrosive nature of the drug war permeates every facet of life, personal and professional.
The episode also tracks the consequences of the system’s indifference. Avon Barksdale, despite Rhonda Pearlman’s vigorous objections as a prosecutor, secures his release through a prior deal with prison authorities eager to be rid of him. Cutty Wise, recently freed after fourteen years inside, struggles profoundly with reintegration, his attempts at legitimate work (landscaping) dismissed as the best he can hope for. This crushing limitation, coupled with the magnetic pull of the only life he knows, drives him back into the arms of the Barksdale organisation. Bodie, now a corner lieutenant himself, greets the returning Cutty with a complex mix of respect and pity, organising a party heavy with drugs and women – a stark, unromanticised welcome back to the only economy that offers him value.
Written by George Pelecanos, David Simon’s long-time collaborator and chronicler of urban America, Hamsterdam succeeds where the preceding Dead Soldiers stumbled. Pelecanos masterfully interweaves the disparate plot strands – Colvin’s social experiment, McNulty’s investigative breakthroughs and personal implosion, Carcetti’s political machinations, Avon’s return, Cutty’s struggle – into a remarkably coherent and thematically dense whole. Director Ernest Dickerson exhibits greater discipline here, avoiding the stylistic flourishes that occasionally muddied Dead Soldiers, favouring instead a more grounded, observational approach that serves the complex narrative. The episode’s only minor misstep might lie in its final moments: the Barkdale Organisation wild party, scored with contemporary hip-hop, feels slightly over-stylised, bordering on the self-consciously "artsy" of a modern rap video. It risks aestheticising the desolation it seeks to critique, momentarily pulling the viewer out of the gritty realism that defines the episode’s power.
Hamsterdam is a devastating critique of American exceptionalism and the persistent, dangerous allure of simplistic European solutions to deeply rooted American pathologies. It exposes the profound naivety of transplanting concepts like Dutch drug tolerance into the uniquely toxic American cocktail of systemic racism, economic abandonment, and a carceral state that has utterly failed its most vulnerable citizens. Colvin’s well-intentioned but ultimately arrogant plan fails not because the idea is inherently flawed in a vacuum, but because it ignores the specific, brutal realities of Baltimore – the lack of trust, the fractured communities, the sheer power of the street economy, and the political cowardice that ensures such experiments can only be clandestine, half-measures. Hamsterdam remains one of The Wire’s most audacious and essential statements on the impossibility of quick fixes in a broken system.
RATING: 8/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Leodex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9