Mirror, Mirror (S02E10)
Airdate: October 6th 1967
Written by: Jerome Bixby
Directed by: Marc Daniels
Running Time: 50 minutes
Star Trek, more than any other science fiction franchise before or since, has demonstrated an extraordinary capacity to interrogate humanity’s hopes and fears through speculative storytelling. This potential was not confined to its depiction of an optimistic future but extended to the creation of alternative realities that challenged its utopian ideals. Nowhere is this more evident than in the Mirror, Mirror, The Original Series Season (TOS) 2 episode which introduced the iconic Mirror Universe—a dystopian counterpart to the Federation’s hopeful vision. Over six decades later, this episode remains a cornerstone of Star Trek’s legacy, celebrated not only for its audacity in reimagining characters and settings but for its prescient exploration of power, tyranny, and the fragility of progress.
The episode’s script, written by the prolific science fiction writer Jerome Bixby, draws loosely from his 1953 short story One Way Street, which explored themes of alternate realities and moral ambiguity. Bixby, renowned for his work on The Twilight Zone, Fantastic Voyage, and The Man from Earth, brought a seasoned hand to TOS. Mirror, Mirror marked the first of four episodes he wrote for the series, and his influence is palpable in the narrative’s tight plotting and thematic depth. While the connection to One Way Street is tenuous, Bixby’s knack for crafting morally complex scenarios and witty dialogue elevates the episode beyond its modest budget and technical constraints.
The story begins on the home planet of the Halkans, an ultra-pacifist humanoid species. Captain Kirk’s mission to negotiate the purchase of dilithium crystals—a resource critical for Federation starships—is met with steadfast refusal, as the Halkans fear their technology will be weaponised. Simultaneously, an ion storm disrupts the Enterprise’s transporters, resulting in Kirk, McCoy, Scotty, and Uhura being accidentally swapped with their doppelgängers from the Mirror Universe. Upon materialising on the ISS Enterprise, they find themselves in a brutal, militaristic regime ruled by the Terran Empire. The Mirror Universe’s inhabitants mirror their TOS counterparts in appearance but are defined by ruthlessness and ambition. A pivotal moment occurs when Mirror-Spock—a chilling, goatee-sporting version of the Vulcan—mistakes Kirk for his counterpart, a confusion the crew exploits to navigate the chaotic politics of the ship. Meanwhile, Mirror-Kirk’s “captain’s woman,” Marlena Moreau (played by Barbara Luna), aids the protagonists, complicating alliances in a world where trust is a liability.
Marc Daniels, a veteran director whose work spanned both episodic television and film, helmed Mirror, Mirror with verve. Despite the era’s limited budgets and technical capabilities, Daniels made inventive use of the Enterprise’s existing sets to distinguish the Mirror Universe. The subtle yet striking differences—such as the ISS prefix and the stark, militaristic decor—communicate the divergence between the two worlds without requiring costly new builds. The claustrophobic setting, confined primarily to the ship’s corridors and bridge, amplifies the tension, as the crew’s every move risks discovery. Daniels’ direction also excels in juxtaposing the two Enterprises: the regular Enterprise’s scenes, though brief, underscore the contrast between the Federation’s idealism and the Empire’s brutality.
One of the episode’s greatest strengths lies in its subversion of familiar characters. The casting choices—actors embodying their roles’ darker counterparts—allowed the ensemble to showcase versatility. George Takei, typically the composed Sulu, delivered a career-defining performance as a scheming, villainous version of himself, while Nimoy’s dual portrayal of Spock and Mirror-Spock was masterful. The latter’s cold logic and calculated ruthlessness contrasted sharply with the original Spock’s restraint, highlighting how environment shapes identity. Even minor characters, like the conspiratorial Chekov and Sulu, were given depth through their Machiavellian intrigues.
Critics may quibble with the decision to retain identical names and appearances for characters across universes—a choice that strains suspension of disbelief. However, this very convention becomes a narrative tool, forcing the audience to confront the fragility of morality. Bixby’s script deftly deals with this premise, using the doppelgängers to explore how power corrupts. For instance, the Mirror-Spock’s adherence to “logic” leads him to side with Kirk, predicting the Empire’s eventual collapse due to its unsustainable tyranny—a poignant nod to Roddenberry’s faith in the Federation’s ideals.
The Mirror Universe’s aesthetic, designed by William Ware Theiss, employed revealing outfits for female characters like Uhura and Marlena Moreau. While this could have veered into exploitation, the context of the dystopian regime justified the choice. Nichelle Nichols and Barbara Luna seized the opportunity, their performances imbuing their characters with agency and cunning rather than objectification. This nuance mitigates accusations of sexism, positioning the costumes as narrative elements rather than distractions.
The Terran Empire’s depiction as an aggressive imperialistic fascist-like force—with the Terran using Roman salute—serves as a sharp contrast to the Federation’s democratic ethos. This divergence challenges Roddenberry’s utopian vision, yet the episode ultimately reinforces his optimism. Mirror-Spock’s defection to Kirk underscores the idea that logic, when untethered from empathy, becomes a tool of oppression. His prediction that the Empire will meet its end hints at the cyclical nature of tyranny, a theme that resonates with modern critiques of authoritarianism.
Mirror, Mirror is not merely a standout episode but a foundational text in Star Trek’s mythos. Though the Mirror Universe was dormant for nearly three decades, it resurfaced in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (DS9), where it explored themes of rebellion and resistance. Later series, including Enterprise and Star Trek: Discovery, further expanded the concept, cementing its place in Trek lore. The episode’s success lies in its ability to balance high-concept ideas with character-driven tension—a hallmark of Bixby’s writing and Daniels’ direction.
Mirror, Mirror is a testament to Star Trek’s audacity and vision. By daring to invert its core ideals, the episode not only challenged its audience but redefined the boundaries of what science fiction could achieve. Its exploration of power, identity, and alternate realities continues to inspire, proving that even within the darkest mirrors, there exists a glimmer of hope. For all its budgetary limitations and occasional narrative quirks, this episode stands as a classic—a reminder that the best sci-fi doesn’t just predict the future; it questions it.
RATING: 8/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9