Moral Midgetry (S03E08)
Airdate: November 14th 2004
Written by: Richard Price
Directed by: Agnieszka Holland
Running Time: 58 minutes
One of the defining characteristics that elevated The Wire beyond mere television into the realm of cultural and artistic embodiment of its era was its creators’ unparalleled ability to deliver plot twists that detonate with initial, visceral shock, yet, upon reflection, resonate with an almost terrifying inevitability. Few moments exemplify this mastery more devastatingly than the earth-shattering cliffhanger that concludes Season 3, Episode 8, Moral Midgetry. What appears, in the fleeting seconds before the screen cuts to black, as a sudden, brutal rupture is, in truth, the logical, horrifying culmination of every thematic thread and character flaw meticulously laid bare throughout the season – a moment where the show’s core thesis about systemic failure and individual moral compromise crystallises into irreversible, bloody consequence.
Prior to Richard Price’s script delivering this narrative sledgehammer, the episode masterfully misdirects the viewer, suggesting its primary concern lies elsewhere. It presents itself as an exploration of ambition run amok, focusing on two major characters whose grand, poorly conceived schemes – each pushing far beyond their station and comprehension – spiral into catastrophic, unintended consequences. The first of these is Major Howard "Bunny" Colvin’s audacious, radical experiment: the creation of "Hamsterdam," designated zones within the Western District where illicit drug trade and associated activities are tacitly tolerated by police. On the surface, Colvin’s gamble appears spectacularly successful. Crime statistics in his jurisdiction plummet so dramatically that higher-ups, steeped in institutional cynicism, immediately suspect cooked books rather than revolutionary policing. Yet, the episode swiftly dismantles this superficial triumph. When Colvin, seeking validation, escorts the respected community elder The Deacon on a tour of Hamsterdam, the anticipated commendation for innovation and safety evaporates. Instead, The Deacon is rendered speechless with horror. Colvin’s solution has not eradicated misery but merely concentrated it. The open-air drug markets thrive alongside rampant prostitution, transforming these zones into grotesque, hyper-visible microcosms of societal collapse. The grim irony is underscored by the opening scene: disarmed dealers become victims of opportunistic stick-up boys, their complaints to police met with dark, bureaucratic indifference – a microcosm of the system’s inherent absurdity. Even Omar Little, the ultimate stick-up artist, wisely avoids the scene, recognising the density of eyes and the precariousness of the arrangement; for him, Hamsterdam isn’t a goldmine but a potential death trap disguised as opportunity, likely to trigger a massive, career-ending drug bust.
This moral vacuum horrifies not only The Deacon but also members of Colvin’s own command. Officer Anthony Colicchio (Benjamin Busch) embodies the institutional conscience Colvin has deliberately bypassed. Colicchio cannot reconcile police tolerance, even encouragement, of mass lawlessness. His discussions with peers reveal the profound ethical fissure within the unit; he explicitly contemplates leaking Hamsterdam’s existence to higher authorities or the media – a single, devastating act that would instantly collapse Colvin’s entire house of cards. Becoming acutely aware of The Deacon’s profound moral condemnation, Colvin attempts damage control, enlisting other activists to mitigate the visible suffering. Children are deputised as informal "police," while supplies, clean needles, and condoms flow in. Cutty Wise, witnessing this fragile ecosystem, finds his own redemption path, sparking the idea for his youth boxing gym – a genuine, human-scale positive emerging from the moral quagmire.
Simultaneously, the episode tracks the parallel, equally doomed ambition of Stringer Bell. His dream of transitioning from ruthless drug kingpin to legitimate businessman continues to founder on the jagged rocks of his fundamental misunderstanding of power structures. Where he excelled at dealing with the brutal logic of the streets, he flounders when confronting the smooth, deeply entrenched corruption of figures like State Senator Clay Davis. His latest scheme – securing a lucrative federal grant – hits another snag, one Davis will inevitably exploit to his own advantage. However, Stringer’s far greater peril stems from the widening chasm with Avon Barksdale and, catastrophically, his cold-blooded decision to silence Avon’s nephew, D’Angelo Barksdale, in prison. The fake suicide, while unlikely to ever be investigated as murder (a reality McNulty bitterly acknowledges), becomes the instrument of Stringer’s downfall. McNulty uses D’Angelo’s death to confront his grieving mother, Briana, forcing her complicity in her son’s life choices into the open. Briana, in turn, confronts Stringer. His denials ring hollow; he knows the jig is up, that Avon’s suspicions will soon crystallise into lethal certainty. In a moment of fatal miscalculation, Stringer confesses the murder to Avon, triggering a physical altercation.
Herein lies one of the episode’s most profound ironies: Stringer’s victory in this fight – overcoming the physically dominant Avon – is itself the direct result of another critical blunder. His ill-advised attempt to broker peace with the ruthless newcomer Marlo Stanfield was perceived by Marlo as weakness, provoking a devastating war. During a botched trap set by Avon using the young woman Devonne (Tiara Harris) as bait, Marlo’s enforcers, Chris Partlow and Snoop, reverse the ambush, killing one of Avon’s men and critically wounding Avon himself in the shoulder. It is Avon’s injury, limiting his mobility and strength, that allows the "softer" Stringer to prevail in their subsequent confrontation. Victory, in this world, is often born of prior, unacknowledged failure. While the Major Crimes Unit (MCU) diligently traces burner phone purchases to Bernard, laying groundwork for future cases, the true narrative tension builds relentlessly towards the fracture at the heart of the Barksdale organisation.
The episode also offers moments of levity that underscore the show’s thematic depth. The most darkly humorous sequence involves McNulty’s cringe-inducing attempt to ingratiate himself with a rural Virginia sheriff. Assuming stereotypical redneck racism, McNulty clumsily plays to these supposed prejudices, only to be spectacularly humiliated when the sheriff reveals his Black wife and deputy. It’s a masterclass in exposing McNulty’s own ingrained biases and the absurdity of his self-perceived cleverness. Similarly, Tina d’Agostino’s coaching of Tommy Carcetti to downplay his intellect and adopt a "folksy" persona, referencing JFK, Reagan, and Clinton, inadvertently sketches Carcetti as a nascent political archetype – a proto-Obama figure navigating the performative demands of modern politics – a subtle foreshadowing of the political season to come.
Written by the incomparable Richard Price – whose daughter Genevieve Hudson-Price appears in a fleeting cameo as a drug buyer in Hamsterdam – "Moral Midgetry" culminates in a cliffhanger of unparalleled narrative weight, echoing the seismic impact of All Prologue from the previous season (where Price himself made a cameo). The resolution of the Stringer-Avon confrontation isn’t reconciliation, but the creation of an insurmountable, blood-soaked chasm between the two men. Their partnership, the bedrock of the Barksdale organisation, is shattered not by external force, but by Stringer’s own hubris, his fatal misreading of the streets, and his catastrophic moral midgetry in believing he could operate outside the brutal code that governed them.
This devastating conclusion is rendered with exceptional craft under the direction of Agnieszka Holland, the highly respected Polish filmmaker whose distinct visual style and profound understanding of human drama brought a unique gravitas to this pivotal episode (she would return to direct another crucial instalment later in the series). Further anchoring the episode in the gritty reality that defined The Wire, Fran Boyd – the real-life subject whose harrowing experiences formed the basis of David Simon’s book The Corner, widely regarded as the spiritual precursor to The Wire – appears in a poignant cameo as a needle exchange worker within Hamsterdam. Her presence is a silent testament to the show’s unwavering commitment to grounding its fictional narrative in the brutal, unvarnished truth of Baltimore’s struggles.
Moral Midgetry stands as a towering achievement not merely for its shocking climax, but for the meticulous, unsparing way it constructs the inevitability of that climax. It dissects the fatal hubris of Colvin’s well-intentioned but morally bankrupt social experiment and Stringer Bell’s delusional belief in transcending the streets through half-understood business logic. Both men, in their distinct spheres, attempt to bend reality to their will, ignoring the fundamental, often brutal, rules of their respective systems. The episode refuses easy judgments, instead forcing the viewer to confront the uncomfortable truth that the path to hell is often paved with pragmatic intentions and ambitious, yet fatally flawed, reasoning.
RATING: 8/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Leodex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9