Q Who (S02E16)
Airdate: May 8th 1989
Written by: Michael Hurley
Directed by: Rob Bowman
Running Time: 46 minutes
It is widely acknowledged among Star Trek scholars and devotees that The Next Generation truly shed the lingering shadow of The Original Series and its cinematic successors during its second season, evolving from a promising imitation into a distinct, confident entity. While pinpointing the exact moment of this maturation might spark spirited debate among fans, the watershed event became undeniably clear with the introduction of a villainous force that would not only redefine the series but rapidly embed itself within the bedrock of global popular culture. That pivotal moment arrived with the episode Q Who, an instalment whose significance transcends mere narrative; it irrevocably altered the trajectory of Star Trek, transforming it from a comfortable continuation into a franchise grappling with genuinely existential threats. The arrival of the Borg was not merely a new monster-of-the-week; it was the injection of a profound, chilling darkness that exposed the Federation’s perceived utopia as terrifyingly fragile.
The episode masterfully leverages the established dynamic with the omnipotent, capricious Q. Captain Picard’s mundane journey in a turbolift is abruptly interrupted as he finds himself inexplicably deposited within a shuttlecraft, confronted by the smirking entity. Q, claiming exile from the Q Continuum, presents himself as a potential boon to the Enterprise, offering his god-like powers to "assist" the crew. Picard, ever wary of Q’s chaotic nature and the potential violation of the Prime Directive, firmly rejects the offer. Q’s response is characteristically petulant yet devastatingly consequential: he instantly catapults the Enterprise some seven thousand light-years into uncharted space, stranding the vessel in a region requiring a two-year journey to return home. This act of cosmic vandalism sets the stage for the episode’s core conflict. Seeking to utilise the unexpected detour for exploration, Picard directs the ship towards the nearby system J-25, despite urgent, uncharacteristically fearful warnings from Guinan, the enigmatic bartender of Ten Forward. Her palpable hostility upon encountering Q hints at a deep, ancient, and unresolved history between them, a mystery deliberately left tantalisingly unexplored.
Within system J-25, the Enterprise discovers the chilling aftermath of advanced civilisation – not destroyed, but utterly stripped, its technology systematically harvested. The perpetrators are swiftly identified: the Borg. This collective, a race of cybernetically augmented humanoids operating under a single, relentless hive mind, possesses an insatiable imperative to assimilate all technology and biological distinctiveness they encounter. Guinan’s visceral reaction is tragically explained; centuries prior, the Borg had nearly succeeded in exterminating her entire speciesy. The encounter escalates with horrifying efficiency. A lone Borg scout drone materialises aboard the Enterprise, its single-minded scavenging of technology utterly impervious to the crew’s desperate, conventional countermeasures. When destroyed, a second drone replaces it, successfully beaming out with stolen components. A brutal engagement ensues, with the Borg’s tractor beam nearly overwhelming the Enterprise; only sustained phaser fire breaks the hold, but not before eighteen crew members perish. An away team led by Riker, Worf, and Data beams onto the cube, encountering a nightmarish vista: thousands of drone-like humanoids moving with eerie synchronicity, utterly oblivious to the intruders amidst the cavernous, biomechanical interior. Their hasty retreat and the Enterprise’s narrow escape prove futile; the Borg cube, vastly superior in speed and resilience, pursues relentlessly. Facing annihilation and the potential assimilation of Earth, Picard is forced into the humiliating position of pleading for Q’s intervention. Q, with characteristic theatricality, instantly returns the ship to Federation space. He vanishes, leaving Guinan to deliver the final, grim pronouncement: the Borg now know of the Federation, and they will come.
The Borg’s impact cannot be overstated. They stand, unequivocally, as the most iconic and enduring alien race conceived for The Next Generation, arguably surpassing even the Klingons or Romulans in their cultural penetration during Star Trek’s "Golden Age." Their name, "Borg," transcended the show, entering the lexicon as shorthand for relentless, dehumanising collectivism and technological assimilation. Its resonance is such that it even served as the moniker for one of Croatia’s most notorious economic and political scandals of the 2010s – the "Agrokor Borg" affair – a testament to the concept’s pervasive cultural shorthand for predatory corporate absorption.
The mere creation of the Borg was a saga born from Season 1’s struggles. Gene Roddenberry had initially envisioned the Ferengi as the primary new antagonists, first name-dropped in Encounter at Farpoint, but their grotesque, avaricious portrayal in The Last Outpost proved a critical misfire, leading to their abandonment as serious threats. Producer Maurice Hurley then attempted a hive-mind concept with the parasitic insects in Conspiracy. The Season 1 finale, The Neutral Zone, explicitly set up a mysterious, technologically advanced attacker of Federation and Romulan outposts, intended to be revealed as the Borg . However, the 1988 Writers Guild of America strike and budget constraints forced this reveal to be scrapped, delaying the Borg’s debut. When they finally emerged in Q Who, it was a triumph of narrative necessity and creative refinement.
The Borg represented a quantum leap in Star Trek antagonism. They were the most alien and undeniably the most menacing force encountered up to that point. Their cyborg appearance – a fusion of decaying flesh and invasive machinery – was viscerally unsettling. Their zombie-like, emotionless movement and single-minded purpose rendered them incapable of negotiation, reason, or conventional defeat. They were not conquerors seeking territory or resources in a familiar sense; they were an evolutionary imperative, a force of nature bent on assimilation. Crucially, the Borg embodied the darkest, most profound philosophical threat within the Star Trek universe: the absolute, terrifying indifference of the cosmos to individual human (or humanoid) life, dignity, or freedom. The Federation’s cherished ideals of self-determination and individual worth were rendered utterly meaningless against an enemy that saw only components to be harvested.
This existential dread was masterfully realised not just through the script, but through Rob Bowman’s taut direction, Ron Jones’s appropriately ominous score, and, most significantly, the groundbreaking production design. The Borg cube’s interior, with its vast, dimly lit corridors pulsating with organic-mechanical infrastructure, was a technical marvel for late-1980s television. It struck a unique aesthetic balance, presaging the biomechanical horror introduced by H. R. Giger in Alien while simultaneously evoking the nightmarish vision of humanity reduced to mere cogs within an immense, indifferent machine – a concept that would resonate powerfully in The Matrix a decade later. The scene within the Borg nursery, where humanoid infants are shown undergoing cybernetic augmentation, remains one of the most disturbing and thematically rich sequences in the entire franchise, crystallising the horror of losing one’s very identity at birth.
Q Who also benefits immensely from its deft handling of established characters. John de Lancie delivers another masterclass as Q, his performance subtly suggesting a potential diminishment of his absolute power within the Continuum, adding layers to his motivations for targeting the Enterprise. Whoopi Goldberg, already a recurring presence as Guinan, is elevated to iconic status here. Her ability to confront Q with genuine authority and the palpable, ancient fear she exhibits towards the Borg creates a compelling dynamic. The hinted-at history between Guinan and Q, and the deeper trauma of her people’s near-annihilation, adds profound depth to both characters, even if the series frustratingly never fully explored these mysteries.
Hurley’s script excels not only in its immediate execution but in its structural brilliance. It builds upon the subtle hints of a larger galactic menace seeded in Season 1 (particularly The Neutral Zone), while simultaneously laying the unshakeable foundation for decades of future storytelling. It directly sets up the apocalyptic stakes of The Best of Both Worlds, influences the Borg-centric narratives of Deep Space Nine and Voyager, and casts a long shadow even over later films like Star Trek: First Contact. Ironically, the very potency of the Borg as an adversary became a narrative constraint; their overwhelming power made convincing defeats difficult to engineer, leading the writers to deploy them relatively sparingly throughout TNG’s run, reserving them for truly pivotal moments.
If the episode harbours a significant flaw, it lies in the ill-conceived introduction of Ensign Sonya Gomez. This rookie officer, clumsily portrayed as a ditsy comic relief figure prone to spilling things and making wide-eyed declarations, represents a jarring tonal dissonance within the otherwise relentlessly serious and terrifying narrative. Her scenes, particularly the initial encounter with Picard where her ineptitude borders on sitcom caricature, feel utterly alien to the episode’s grim atmosphere and thematic weight. Intended as a potential love interest for Geordi La Forge, the character was largely abandoned after only one other appearance. Played by Lycia Naff, whose subsequent fame stemmed from the role of three-breasted prostitute in Total Recall, Gomez’s brief tenure feels like a misstep born of early-season uncertainty about female crew dynamics. Naff’s later, more successful career in journalism feels almost poetically appropriate, given the character’s unfortunate disconnect from the Enterprise’s intellectual rigour.
Q Who is far more than a great Star Trek episode; it is the crucible in which The Next Generation truly found its voice and its place in science fiction history. It moved the series beyond the moral parables and political allegories of its first season into the realm of genuine, universe-altering peril. By introducing the Borg – a villain whose menace stemmed not from ideology but from absolute, dehumanising indifference – the episode delivered a profound philosophical challenge to the Federation’s core ideals. The consensus that Season 2 marked TNG’s true maturation is irrefutable, and Q Who stands as the undeniable catalyst.
RATING: 8/10 (+++)
Blog in Croatian https://draxblog.com
Blog in English https://draxreview.wordpress.com/
InLeo blog https://inleo.io/@drax.leo
LeoDex: https://leodex.io/?ref=drax
InLeo: https://inleo.io/signup?referral=drax.leo
Hiveonboard: https://hiveonboard.com?ref=drax
Rising Star game: https://www.risingstargame.com?referrer=drax
1Inch: https://1inch.exchange/#/r/0x83823d8CCB74F828148258BB4457642124b1328e
BTC donations: 1EWxiMiP6iiG9rger3NuUSd6HByaxQWafG
ETH donations: 0xB305F144323b99e6f8b1d66f5D7DE78B498C32A7
BCH donations: qpvxw0jax79lhmvlgcldkzpqanf03r9cjv8y6gtmk9